Skip to main content
The open tank of a white toilet, its lid set aside, showing the flush valve inside

Best Flushing Toilets by the Numbers: MaP Scores, Gallons per Flush and WaterSense

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product links on this page may be affiliate links.

Last reviewed: November 2026. Sources last checked November 2026.

The number that measures how well a toilet flushes is the MaP score: the grams of waste, paper included, it clears in a single flush. MaP's list tops out at 1,000 g, and 2,105 of its 2,795 scored models sit at exactly that figure, so the highest score is a tie among three-quarters of the scored models. Gallons per flush (gpf) tells you how much water a flush uses, not how well it clears. WaterSense sets a water ceiling of 1.28 gpf plus a pass-or-fail clearing test, and MaP PREMIUM asks for 1.1 gpf and at least 600 g.

Below: what each number means, what MaP's published list shows when you count it, and the scores for the models in our other guides. We have not tested any toilet. Every figure comes from MaP, the EPA, federal law or a maker's spec sheet, and each is linked.

Table of Contents
  1. What a MaP score is
  2. What MaP's list shows when you count it
  3. Gallons per flush: 1.6, 1.28 and 1.1
  4. What WaterSense requires
  5. What MaP PREMIUM requires
  6. Scores for the models in our other guides
  7. Reading the numbers when you compare
  8. Sources

What a MaP score is

MaP Testing defines the score as "the weight in grams of the maximum amount of waste that can be fully evacuated from the toilet in a single flush (including toilet paper)" (MaP, toilet search). The EPA describes the same test as measuring "the maximum quantity of soybean paste test media (up to 1,000 grams) that toilets can clear" (EPA, WaterSense Performance Overview: Tank-Type Toilets, April 2022). So a higher number means a heavier load cleared in one flush, and 1,000 g is the top of the scale.

MaP's search page labels its own bands: 1,000 to 600 g "Highly Recommended", 600 to 350 g "Recommended", 350 to 250 g "Acceptable" and 250 to 0 g "Not Recommended". The list itself says that models without a score "have not been MaP tested" (MaP downloads page, list dated September 24, 2026). A missing score is not a low score. It means no MaP result is published for that model.

What MaP's list shows when you count it

Source: MaP's "Tank-Type and Electro-Hydraulic Toilet Models" list, dated September 24, 2026, consulted November 17, 2026 (MaP downloads). The counts are our arithmetic on that file. The sheet has 6,617 listed models. Of those, 2,795 carry a MaP score and 3,822 carry none. Across the whole list the scores take only nine values: 300, 350, 400, 450, 500, 600, 800, 900 and 1,000 g.

MaP score All scored models Of those, marked WaterSense Of those, marked MaP PREMIUM
1,000 g 2,105 1,658 237
800 to 999 g 501 405 178
600 to 799 g 142 110 57
350 to 599 g 45 26 0
Under 350 g 2 0 0
Total scored 2,795 2,199 472

Source: MaP list dated September 24, 2026, consulted November 17, 2026; counts by us. The 800 to 999 g row is 500 models at 800 g and one at 900 g. The 600 to 799 g row is all 600 g.

Three things stand out.

  • The list has a ceiling. No model scores above 1,000 g, and 75% of scored models (2,105 of 2,795) score exactly 1,000 g. That fits the EPA's "up to 1,000 grams". We found no source explaining why so many land on the ceiling, so we state it as a count and nothing more. It does mean the MaP list cannot rank those 2,105 models against each other.
  • Most listed models carry no score. 3,822 of 6,617 rows (58%) have none. 5,997 rows are marked WaterSense, but only 2,199 of those have a score; the other 3,798 are marked WaterSense without a MaP result.
  • A high score does not require low water use. 447 of the 596 scored models that are not marked WaterSense also score 1,000 g. One example from the list: TOTO's CST776CSF(G).10 carries a note that it "flushes at 1.6 gal (6.0 Litres)" and scores 1,000 g. A high score and a low gpf are two separate facts.

The lowest scores in the list are two models at 300 g, and neither is marked WaterSense. The lowest WaterSense-marked score is 350 g, which matches the clearing requirement below.

Gallons per flush: 1.6, 1.28 and 1.1

Gallons per flush (gpf) is the water a flush uses. Three ceilings matter, and they stack.

Ceiling Water per flush Applies to Source
Federal maximum 1.6 gpf Gravity tank-type toilets manufactured after January 1, 1994 42 U.S.C. 6295(k); 10 CFR 430.32(q)
WaterSense, version 1.2 1.28 gpf (4.8 liters) Tank-type toilets carrying the label EPA specification v1.2
MaP PREMIUM 1.1 gpf (4.0 liters) Single-flush; a dual-flush full flush may be 1.28 gpf MaP PREMIUM

Source: the linked texts, checked November 17, 2026. The federal rule gives 1.6 gpf for gravity tank-type, flushometer tank and electromechanical hydraulic toilets alike. EPA puts the WaterSense level in context: 1.28 gpf is "20 percent less water than the current federal standard of 1.6 gallons per flush" (EPA, residential toilets). For dual-flush toilets WaterSense counts the effective flush volume as the average of two reduced flushes and one full flush, which is why a dual-flush model can show a full-flush number above 1.28.

What WaterSense requires

Two parts, one on water and one on clearing.

Water. Version 1.2 of the specification, effective June 2, 2014, says the effective flush volume "shall not exceed 1.28 gallons (4.8 liters)" (EPA, Specification for Tank-Type Toilets v1.2). This is the version in force. EPA's page says "Version 1.2 remains in effect until further notice" after it paused the effective date of version 2.0, released in May 2024 (EPA, residential toilets). We use 1.2 throughout.

Clearing. The same specification calls a model's flush performance a "pass" or "fail": it must clear all the test media in a single flush "in at least four of five attempts". Version 1.2 does not write out the grams; it points to a national standard. EPA's 2022 overview does: WaterSense requires toilets "to clear 350 grams of soybean paste test media and four balls of toilet paper from the bowl in four of five test flushes". EPA says it chose 350 g from a medical study of human waste, where "the 99.5 percent confidence level of the men in the study equates to a loading of approximately 350 grams" (EPA, Performance Overview, April 2022). The same document says these requirements have since been adopted into the ASME A112.19.2/CSA B45.1 standard, so all toilets sold in the United States or Canada must meet them, WaterSense or not.

That is why MaP and WaterSense overlap: a WaterSense toilet has cleared 350 g in the WaterSense test, and MaP then reports how much more it can clear, up to 1,000 g. In the list, every WaterSense-marked model with a score is at 350 g or above.

What MaP PREMIUM requires

MaP PREMIUM asks for three things at once: the toilet is certified to WaterSense, its effective flush volume is no more than 4.0 liters (1.1 gallons), and its MaP score is at least 600 g. MaP states that "MaP PREMIUM DOES NOT INCLUDE NOR ALLOW ANY TOILETS WITH A 1.6 GALLON (6 LITRE) FLUSH", and that a dual-flush fixture's full flush may reach 1.28 gallons (MaP PREMIUM, last updated June 25, 2026).

In the September 24 list, 561 rows carry the PREM mark. 472 of them have a MaP score: 237 at 1,000 g, 178 at 800 g and 57 at 600 g, none below 600 g, as the requirement says. The other 89 PREM-marked rows show no score in the list; we do not know why, and we do not count them in the distribution. MaP's own PREMIUM page counts 479 models available at retail on a different date, so the two totals are not meant to match.

Scores for the models in our other guides

Searched by model number in the same MaP list (September 24, 2026; consulted November 17, 2026). The list gives no gpf, so the gpf column is from each maker's sheet.

Model MaP score in the list Marked WaterSense Marked PREM gpf from the maker's sheet
TOTO Drake CST776CEFG.10 (list row: CST776CEF(G).10) 1,000 g Yes No 1.28 (TOTO)
Kohler Highline K-6393 1,000 g Yes No 1.1 or 1.6 (Kohler)
Kohler Cimarron K-3851 (also K-3851-U) no MaP score in the list Yes No 1.28 (Kohler)
Kohler Wellworth K-3948-U (also K-3948) 1,000 g Yes No 1.28 (Kohler)
American Standard Cadet PRO 215FC.104 1,000 g Yes No 1.28 (American Standard)
American Standard Cadet 3 270AB.101 no MaP score in the list Yes No 1.28 (American Standard)

Source: MaP list, September 24, 2026, consulted November 17, 2026; gpf from the linked sheets. The Highline's score is for the model as MaP lists it; the maker's sheet offers a choice of 1.1 or 1.6 gpf, and the list gives no gpf for it. American Standard's own sheet for the Cadet PRO says "1,000g MaP Score" at 1.28 gpf, and its sheet for the round-front Cadet 3 270D says the same at 1.6 gpf (American Standard 270D sheet). That is the same point as the TOTO note above: 1,000 g appears at both 1.6 and 1.28 gpf. The Cadet 3 page on American Standard's site was marked "Discontinued" when we read it.

The two "no MaP score" rows are WaterSense models, so they cleared WaterSense's 350 g test. The list publishes no MaP result for them, and we do not guess one.

Reading the numbers when you compare

  • Look up the exact model number. The list has separate rows for variants (a lined tank, a different bowl, a different tank). A score belongs to the row, not to the brand or the line.
  • Use the score as a filter, not a ranking. Setting the search to 1,000 g keeps 2,105 models. After that, the facts that separate them are in the maker's sheet: gpf, rough-in, bowl shape and height. See toilet rough-in for the measurement that decides fit, 10-inch rough-in toilets and 14-inch rough-in toilets for the spec sheets by size, and comfort height vs standard toilets for bowl height.
  • Check the water number separately. A 1,000 g score says nothing about gpf, as the 1.6 gpf TOTO row shows. If a low water use matters, look for the WaterSense mark or a 1.28 gpf (or lower) rating on the sheet.
  • A missing score is missing information. Treat "no MaP score" as unknown, and ask the maker or MaP for the model's result if you need it.

If you want to see what is sold online on the day you look, a search for WaterSense toilets on Amazon lists current models; match each one's model number to MaP's list before relying on any score.

Sources

MaP Testing: toilet search, MaP PREMIUM and the downloadable list (September 24, 2026), all checked November 17, 2026. EPA WaterSense: tank-type toilet specification v1.2, residential toilets page and Performance Overview (April 2022). Federal law: 42 U.S.C. 6295(k) and 10 CFR 430.32(q). Maker sheets: TOTO Drake; Kohler K-6393, K-3851 and K-3948-U; American Standard 215F, 270D and the Cadet 3 page. All pages checked November 2026.

If you'd like to read other articles similar to Best Flushing Toilets by the Numbers: MaP Scores, Gallons per Flush and WaterSense You can visit the category Flushing and Water Use.

Go up